Do you feel Match of the Day is better for having pundits or do you feel it would benefit from being a strictly highlight reel show?

The benefits would be longer highlights.

The downside would be the talking points, loss of good analysis etc. 

Erm to be fair I record it watch the high lights then skip forward but i think just the highlight minus the waffle would be great. 

I think it would be worse without the talking segments.

It's just when they waffle on about things and attempt to over analyse what they see. Sometimes the pundits talk out of their bottom and come out with the weirdest things but I do generally enjoy Match of the Day if I had time to watch it. ???? 

i dont watch it very often, i find the premier league uninteresting tbh.

I enjoy watching it, I wouldn’t get rid of the pundits but would cut out some of the waffle to make more football clips.

It's fine as it is, it breaks things up. Watching highlights only would be a little boring.

I enjoy it as it is, I see no reason to fix what isn't broken.

I wished the Football League show would be more like Match of the Day, there's nothing wrong with the current format IMO.

MOTD is fine, one of the best football shows available to watch.