ryan schofield

jim o'brien

mitch rose

michael doyle

craig mackail smith

sam stubbs

virgil gomis

ben barclay

all appear to be solid additions that brings some sort of special quality to the team. who do you think is the best signing of them all and why?

 

Craig Mackail-Smith or Michael Doyle.

I'm split between because they're offer so much but for different reasons, it might be a little early to judge but I do feel both will be very important to Notts come the end of the season they should have proven this.

I’ll answer that in early May!


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

I have no idea, but judging by the the player ratings they all seem to be a very big improvement on the players they've replaced.

Its abit early to say really. Regardless of how they played for other clubs, its how they play for us that matters.

Craig Mackail-Smith would get my vote, however it is early and my opinion could change 3-5 games later.

I'm not sure it will because Mackail-Smith looks like a proper footballer who gets a buzz from putting on the shirt and playing, I think he actually enjoys causing mayhem to the opposition defence and I think this comes as standard.

Wow, what a question ! After one game there is such a massive improvement it’s hard to say. Everyone was superp. Doyle will get the plaudits and having the foresight to scuff the spot up before Lincoln’s penalty was sheer inspiration, ungentlemanly yes but the ultimate professional.

I thought Stubbs and Barclay were absolutely fantastic for such young lads. CMC showed what putting one’s heart & soul into a game means and with Doyle as a partner O’Brien shon as well.

what a difference it makes having someone to stand in for Tootle at RB. We couldn’t have asked for more from Rose playing out of position.

all in all we have now seen what Neal Ardley can be to this club, something the 2 previous managers were incapable of doing. 1 recruit, 2 motivate and 3 organise. 

Doyle for me, so far. 

I think the total some is greater than any one part to be honest. It wasn't until all of the signings came together that we have started to look better, so I feel it would be unfair to single out one player in particular.

Jim O'Brien has given his best in all of the games I have seen, he would be mine.

Craig Mackail-Smith looks to be the best player out of a very good amount of signings, his fight and never give up attitude should help no end.

I think they're all very good, I cannot choose or single out just one but Michael Doyle, Craig Mackail-Smith and Jim O'Brien all seem very good players.

2 hours ago, CliftonMagpie said:

Craig Mackail-Smith looks to be the best player out of a very good amount of signings, his fight and never give up attitude should help no end.

He did look very good in the game.

Ryan Schofield played 2 conceded 2 but has given confidence to the players in front of him, I bet Ross Fitzsimons would still struggle.

I think Virgil Gomis will prove his worth, he seems a very exciting prospect and one that offers the club a lot.

craig mackail smith

All the new signings seem to have fitted in very well.